EMP vs. solar storm: what is the difference?
What does EMP mean here?
EMP stands for electromagnetic pulse. This page uses it for a high-altitude nuclear burst (often called HEMP). Other sources of pulses are not covered here. A solar storm is a separate natural event. The two get mixed together online, and the evidence for one does not carry over to the other.
What are E1, E2 and E3?
The EMP Commission's 2004 Executive Report splits a high-altitude pulse into three parts.
- E1 is the fast pulse.
- E2 is similar to lightning. The Commission says it is not an issue for infrastructure that already has lightning protection, except when combined with earlier E1 damage.
- E3 is a slow pulse that drives currents in long power lines.
The US Department of Energy's 2024 transformer report adds that E3 is similar to a geomagnetic disturbance (the solar storm effect) but can produce larger fields.
How does NOAA rate solar storms?
NOAA's Space Weather Prediction Center uses a G-scale for geomagnetic storms. G1 corresponds to a Kp index of 5 and G5 to a Kp index of 9. For G5, NOAA lists widespread voltage-control problems, possible grid collapse, and says transformers may experience damage.
What does each event threaten?
The two events reach the grid by different routes. Based on the sources we read:
| Question | Nuclear high-altitude EMP | Solar storm |
|---|---|---|
| Cause | Nuclear burst at high altitude | Geomagnetic disturbance from the Sun |
| Fast pulse (E1) | Yes. EPRI studied its effect on digital relays | No equivalent |
| Slow pulse (E3) | Yes, and the DOE says the fields can be larger | Yes, this is the whole event |
| Main concern in the sources we read | Electronics and relays (E1), long lines and transformers (E3) | Long lines, voltage control and transformers |
| Rating | Not covered in the sources we read | NOAA G1 to G5 |
| Warning | Not covered in the sources we read | Not covered in the sources we read |
The table cells on warning and rating are labeled by what we read, not a claim that nothing exists. Small consumer electronics are a separate question, covered on what electronics survive an EMP. We found no primary test data on them.
What happened in Quebec in 1989?
NOAA reports that in March 1989 a geomagnetic storm left six million people in Quebec without power for nine hours. That is a documented grid effect from a solar storm. It was not a nuclear event.
What was the Carrington event?
NOAA calls the 1859 Carrington event the largest recorded geomagnetic storm. The effect it recorded was telegraph disruption, because there was no electric grid at the time. No source we read can say what an event that size would do to a modern grid in detail.
What we do not know
- Unknown: how a repeat of the 1859 storm would affect today's grid. The estimates exist but the source we read does not say how they were derived (see how long the grid would be down).
- Unknown: whether the May 2024 G5 storm damaged any grid equipment. NOAA confirmed G5 conditions on May 10 and 11, 2024, but we found no confirmed grid damage from it and do not claim any.
- Unknown: how consumer electronics respond to either event. No primary test data was found.
- CISA calls both EMP and geomagnetic disturbance low-probability, high-consequence events. We do not give odds, because we have no sourced figure.
What to do about it
The household steps that help with either event are the same steps that help with any long outage, so start with the cheapest.
- Store water first. See how much water to store per person.
- Learn how you would make water safe without power: make water safe without power.
- Pick a way to get news. Emergency radio: what to look for lists the features that matter.
- Decide whether backup power is worth it for you: backup power: what to look for.
- If you want to read about shielding products, read do Faraday bags work before buying.
Sources
- EMP Commission, Report of the Commission to Assess the Threat to the United States from Electromagnetic Pulse (EMP) Attack, Vol. 1 Executive Report, 2004. empcommission.org
- NOAA Space Weather Prediction Center, Space Weather Scales. spaceweather.gov
- NOAA NESDIS, When Solar Storms Attack: Space Weather and Our Infrastructure. nesdis.noaa.gov
- US Department of Energy, Large Power Transformer Resilience Report, July 2024. energy.gov
- EPRI Journal, A Deliberate Approach to Electromagnetic Pulses, 2019. eprijournal.com
- CISA, EMP and GMD. cisa.gov
- NOAA Space Weather Prediction Center, G5 conditions reached yet again, May 2024. spaceweather.gov